I recommend Tucker Hill Design on Etsy. The owner, Kathleen, is great to work with and she has great scents. She can even make a custom scent for you. I have six of her products and love them all. They are only $6.25 a bottle. Can't beat it. Give it a try.
I've enjoyed my Rise Cooling Balm(seems to be both an aftershave and a balm). There's a slight fragrance of original Rise, which is nice, but I'd like to have more than just "slight".
Reef Point makes one of the best balms I have tried, excellent stuff! The old Mickey Lee Soapworks aftershave milk is pretty amazing as well.
Nothing fancy here, bought up a Lot of six Avon Black Suede after shave balm for $12.00 on Ebay. It has a slight burn after the shave and nice smell. Will use them until they are done, but my favorite so far is Stetson Black after shave balm and cologne. The balm does not have any burn at all and smells great. It's my "going out" combo, while Avon is for everyday use, at least for now.............