Only have the Green, in both versions(Bigelow, Proraso). As a matter of fact I'm using the Green all this week in my Focus shave. The menthol kick is great first thing in the morning. Followed by a cold towel finish and either Canoe or Clubman AS. Good stuff!
After the Proraso Green (because of the eucalyptus), strangely enough the White feels least pleasant on my face. I guess it's the oatmeal reacting with my skin. For people who are allergic to eucalyptus, Proraso Green is a very bad advice. Just keep that in mind please.
I have and enjoy all (and I mean all) the Proraso products and they are awesome. Always a pleasure when Proraso comes up in my rotation.
I pretty much use Proraso soaps and creams exclusively. I like to pair which ever color Proraso cream I'm using with a like colored after shave splash. For example: Proraso Green - Mennen Skin Bracer, Barbasol Brisk or Proraso green splash. Proraso Red - Pinaud VIBR, Aqua Velva Musk Proraso Blue - Aqua Velva Ice Blue Proraso White - Pinaud Clubman (OK, it's not white or clear, but it's all I got!)
Green tube is my favorite. I can make it really slick with plenty of H2O added slowly. Used the green tub and won't be repurchasing it. It was ok, but not as good.
I can't do menthol. I have the red and it doesn't have menthol. Do all the other creams have menthol?