I think I would have to suggest MWF, Cella and Proraso White. All good quality soaps/creams and excellent performance.
There are a lot of soaps to try out, nowadays. Reef Point, Mike's Natural, Shannon's Soaps, the list goes on. Being from North of the 49 I'd recommend First Canadian Shave Soap company. Right now with the Can. $ trading so low it's $11USD for four ounces, and the overall quality is quite good.