Favorite Lime Aftershaves?

I am a newbie when it comes to lime aftershave. The only one I've tried is Florida Water, and have become quite fond of it.
I have been hearing very good things about Vintage Shulton Old Spice Lime, and English Lather Lime.
So, I ordered some Shulton Old Spice Lime. How does this compare to others out there, including the Indian Old Spice Lime, currently being produced.
What are your favorites? What makes them stand out?

 

The only lime I've tried is Captain's Choice. It happens to be my current go to aftershave and one of my top three! Very natural and soothing. Although it is linear, it dissipates quickly which allows me to use cologne.

 

Here are the two lime AS that I have and Limacol is the one I prefer. The English Leather will look familiar to some people here, I won it in our latest raffle.



Found the Limacol on Amazon.

Dave

 

Vintage Avon Island Lime.

 

I have had my eye out for this for long long time.

Dave

 

I am very fond of Pinaud's Lime Sec and Citrus Musk. I didn't get much lime out of Florida Water. To me it smells like lemongrass with a hint of spicy something.

Lime sec was very sweet lime and nothing else. The citrus musk is milder with a lighter smell. They both last at least 12 hours on me.

 

Living in a small town, local shopping is limited. I visit the three independent beauty supply store as needed, Sally's (nothing on the shelf), and went in the mall so see what Ulta stocks (overpriced). After having a conversation with a clerk at one of the beauty supply stores, I hoped I'd persuaded her to get more Pinaud products in their store. A month later and I still haven't held a bottle of Lime Sec or Citrus Musk.
Thank you @DDuckyMark for the 12 hour linger remark. Pinaud doesn't skimp on scent (see: The Veg) and now I can order online and be hopeful that I like these two also.

 

Royall Lime is very good

But if you can find it anywhere the Pusser's East Indian Lime is AWESOME Yes that Pusser's they make a Bay Rum also and some good drinking Rum

 

I love the Royall Lime. I picked up some Avon Island lime in a motorcycle bottle and that's nice too but not as good as the royall.

 

Avon Island Lime is a great aftershave. My favorite lime is Stephan Island Lime, comes in a huge bottle for around $7-8 the scent lasts longer than any other lime aftershave I have tried. Highly recommend either of these two.

 

I'll have to research that one.
English Leather Lime seems to be expensive. Why? Is it that good, compared to others?

 

Let's see if I can remember all of the lime aftershave I have:

Aqua Velva - Frost Lime
Avon - Island Lime
Booster - Iced Lime
Captain's Choice - Lime
Citrocol Lime
Dominca Bay Rum Lime
English Leather - Lime
Pinaud Clubman - Citrus Musk
Pinaud Clubman - Lime Sec
Royall Lime
Skin Bracer - Dry Lime

Avon's is the best, most true lime scent, which lasts the longest.

 

I've always appreciated your expertise - would you mind doing a brief review of each of those? I've not tried most of those and I'm out of Avon's now (broke my last bottle several months back) but always found it excellent. Tried Royall a few Travel Boxes ago; it was good but liked Avon's better.

Stephan's BR was always my all-around fav so I'm curious about their lime.

 

BTW...does Old Spice Lime smell basically like OS with lime EO added? If it does, I have both and will just whip up some of my own.

 

I've never had any but it's probably simply because it's loooong out of production.

 

I am now suffering from (ASAD)
After Shave Acquisition Disorder

 

Nice travel kit.
I've got that much in all Avon Spicy.
A couple of Deep Woods, a Tai Breeze, Wild Country, and some Brisk Spice.
You don't want to know about my Shulton Old Spice.

 

That'll take some effort. Some of these vintage ones I've only used once or twice. And it's been a while. I'll see what I can do shortly.

And I appreciate your nose when it comes to evaluating Avon scents and comparing them to others.