New or vintage?

Hello all,
I'm sure this question has been asked a lot, but I would like opinions on whether to go with a new DE razor or vintage. Currently I am using a Parker retro that I don't really like. As I mentioned in my first post, I am returning to DE shaving after a couple of years (not really sure why I ever stopped DE shaving anyway.) Whichever route I eventually go, I do plan on getting a blade sampler. Any and all suggestions would be appreciated.

 

I'd go with a vintage super speed to start out. It's a great place to start with vintage razors and an all around great razor! You'll save a lot if money too. Although I just got a wsp el grande and love it for $25!

 

I went with a "new" Edwin Jagger DE89. And moved to vintage once my technique was sound.

 

Should you go new or vintage? The answer is yes.

 

I agree. The answer is yes.

 

I would go new. You have a warranty and have a vendor to address any issues that may arise. Once you get more acclimated and know the common problems, then grab some vintage gear.

 

New. Until you drop it and it shatters. And mostly all are 3-piece which I find annoying to load.Vintage super speeds can have a lot of problems (They're brass so they just bend don't break) because of all the small mechanical parts. Your best bet is a vintage 3-piece Tech. Annoying to load but better built than new pot metal razors. Less that can go wrong than with a Super Speed.

 

Lol, I wish I could but just starting a new job, so not a lot of cash right now.

 

The only way you're going to know is try some of both because there are hundreds to choose from and no one really can tell you what will work best for you.

 

Honestly I really love the WSP el grande. It's gorgeous, well made, feels good in the hand and at $25 you can't beat it.

 

Really tight on a budget? I'd recommend the Lord L6, I own my fair share of new and vintage, and I use this cheap little bugger probably 90% of the time.

 

I agree with Dridecker Lord,Weishi,Yuma,Rapid are all cheap yet "VERY" servicable razors..They can be excellent choices for a shaver on a budget....They are basically made of the same material as the more expensive EJ,Muhle,Merkur etc although in general the fit, finish and plating is better on these razors..I.M.O.
Although you need to know what your buying, do your due diligence, do alot of reseach and ask "ALOT" of questions of the seller to determine the condition of a vintage razor, they should be considered I.M.O. a step up and comparable to stainless steel.....
As I also agree with Tom, in that the only way to know what razor really works best for you is to try it....So while any way you decide to go is perfectly legitimate, starting cheap and working your way up is a good way....

 

Both. Start with EJ89 then get a Super Speed.

 

I have found as of late, it is a sellers market for vintage razors. Of course, with diligence and luck there are exceptions. Start with new. There are some outstanding affordable options. Bide your time looking for vintage until you develop clearer preferences.

 

Even though I love the vintage razors, I'd probably suggest going with a new one. There have been several good options mentioned to you, and I'll add one more:

http://www.maggardrazors.com/product-category/safety-razors/maggard-razors-safety-razors/

I've heard good things about these inexpensive razors and they're sold by two really nice folks.

 

The Razorock Mission is also a great deal. $20 for a solid stainless steel handle razor with 20 high quality blades to sample. You really can't go wrong. It can be found on The Italian Barber. If you're into auctions or antique shopping, then you can score a nice vintage Superspeed or Tech for $20-30.

 

I'd look in to the Razzorock line, on the budget, with a solid built to them

 

My understanding is that most super speeds and techs tend to be VERY mild. If that's what's you're looking for, then go for it! That said, if you're looking for something a bit more aggressive then many modern razors can be had at very reasonable prices.
Not to dissuade you from vintage (I love vintage and would love to expand my "armory") however; If you buy new there's usually a lot less to worry about regarding condition, there's a lot less hunting around (which, I admit, is kinda fun but it DOES take time), and it is never a bad thing to support modern companies (help keep this art of ours afloat, ya know?)

 

Thank you everyone for your advice. I'm about 95% decided on a EJ89 first, then a Super Speed.

 

You can't go wrong with that! The EJ89 was my first "real" razor and it did wonderful from the first shave. I even use it to shave my head sometimes.