I think the Soap Commander Endurance I real close to the original(my partial original puck has a very little scent left).
It's worth a shot but don't think it will ever come back. People have been bombarding Combe about the Williams formula for years and they haven't done anything. I'd love to find a NOS puck of Old Spice one day. My only experience with the soap was a small scrap at the bottom of a OS mug I picked up. There was only enough for one test lather but it worked up to a beautiful thick stable yogurt consistency.
I try once a year to get P&G to give me the formula for OldSpice shave soap. I argue with them about how thay have not made the soap since the nineties. I always get the same canned answers. Greg W.
Keep trying. So far, NOBODY has duplicated the Old Spice scent. What's odd is, on ALL my other colognes I'm able to find DEAD ON MATCHES for the scent, even on $300 Creed colognes. But Old Spice has NO 'matches'. Seriously, Old Spice must be one difficult fragrance to crack the code on.