Poll: Arko vs. Williams

Discussion in 'Shave Soaps' started by DaltonGang, Nov 28, 2016.

?

Which do you prefer, if you had to choose between the two?

  1. Arko

  2. Williams

Results are only viewable after voting.
  1. Screwtape

    Screwtape A Shaving Butterfly

    Are you suggesting Williams started life as a saddle soap? :cool: :p
     
  2. Spyder

    Spyder Well-Known Member

    No, but (imho) that's all that it's good for:)
     
    Jorvaljr and swarden43 like this.
  3. DaltonGang

    DaltonGang Ol' Itchy Whiskers

    Saddle soap smells better. :D
     
    brit, Jorvaljr and Spyder like this.
  4. Screwtape

    Screwtape A Shaving Butterfly

    Funny thing is, when you consider how long Williams has been made and what the big commercial cleansers were then, Williams might well have started in the harness soap business and only later branched out to serving shavers. (Not saying it did, because I haven't tried to research the company history, but it is certainly possible.)

    Edit: I read that Mr Williams went into the soap business in 1840, producing "Genuine Yankee Soap" , which was sold as both a shaving and toilet (hand, face and bath) soap. He did this though after 6 years in the general store business. I wonder what kind of cleansers he was stocking, selling, and experimenting with during that period before starting commercial soap making? :angelic007: ;)
     
    Last edited: Nov 29, 2016
    Jorvaljr, DaltonGang and Spyder like this.
  5. Carbide Mike

    Carbide Mike 9 Lives

    I have a half dozen boxes of Williams from a long time ago. It is the same stuff available now, or different. ?. Curious. Any feedback will be appreciated
     
    Jorvaljr likes this.
  6. Screwtape

    Screwtape A Shaving Butterfly

    Depends on how "a long time ago" is. If it's more than a decade, then the stuff has been reformulated at least once and possibly more than that since yours was made. And the near universal opinion across the boards seems to be that each reformulation has primarily been to cut costs and has downgraded the product.

    I couldn't say myself; I have never used any really old Williams to compare with newer stuff. And I turned my own newer stuff into bath soap...
     
    DaltonGang and Carbide Mike like this.
  7. Jorvaljr

    Jorvaljr Operation Daytona 8000

    I've heard the old stuff was better than the newer stuff. I can't find Williams locally here so I haven't had the pleasure ( or misfortune) of using it.
     
    Carbide Mike likes this.
  8. Carbide Mike

    Carbide Mike 9 Lives

    I believe I purchased it in 1999. It appears that it is a different color, more off white ,than the newer one I purchased last year.
     
  9. Screwtape

    Screwtape A Shaving Butterfly

    I'm pretty sure at least one of the changes was in the last decade, so yours probably is a different formula than the current stuff.
     
  10. Carbide Mike

    Carbide Mike 9 Lives

    Thank you for the information. I am curious about it, and will pick up a new Williams and compare to the older stock I saved. My last new Williams went into the shower. lol. I will post if there is any difference .Thanks again.
     
    Jayaruh likes this.
  11. 178-bplatoon

    178-bplatoon Well-Known Member

    Having successfully lathered both Arko and newer(made in last 10 yrs) Williams, Arko is the better of the two IMO. Only downside with Arko is it can't be purchased locally.:(
     
    Carbide Mike likes this.
  12. Carbide Mike

    Carbide Mike 9 Lives

    I am hoping to get some Arko this week. Thank you
     
    Jayaruh and SpeedyPC like this.
  13. SpeedyPC

    SpeedyPC Well-Known Member

    @Carbide Mike make sure you don't have a strong scent of smell.............................................Be aware!!!!
     
    Carbide Mike likes this.
  14. 178-bplatoon

    178-bplatoon Well-Known Member

    I use Arko daily it's my go to soap. I haven't used another soap in years. I think you'll like it. I cut the stick up and mash it into a small Ziplock container and use it as a puck mostly.:)
     
    SpeedyPC and Carbide Mike like this.
  15. Carbide Mike

    Carbide Mike 9 Lives

    Sounds like I will do the same.
     
  16. DaltonGang

    DaltonGang Ol' Itchy Whiskers

    :taunt002:
     
    Carbide Mike and SpeedyPC like this.
  17. Terry Williams

    Terry Williams Well-Known Member

    Inspite of the name, I have to go with Arko. It is just easier to lather and easier on my face. I have exactly the opposite problem to @poppi with Williams.
     
    PickledNorthern likes this.
  18. Jayaruh

    Jayaruh The Cackalacky House Pet

    Supporting Vendor
    December will be Arko month for me. I put it in an old deodorant container. I like just rubbing it on my face and building my lather right there.
    sod161201.JPG
     
  19. DaltonGang

    DaltonGang Ol' Itchy Whiskers

    That's the way it's meant to be used. I need to do it that way, once in a while.
     
  20. Primotenore

    Primotenore missed opera tunity

    Article Team
    Maybe the old deodorant container will be helpful...:happy097:
     
    Carbide Mike, PLAla and SpeedyPC like this.

Share This Page