In this list the Art of Shaving lavander shaving cream is listed as 3 in ranking number 30 and 4 in ranking number 46....Brilliant list....
The one ranked at 30 is the regular Lavender shave cream, the one ranked at 46 says it is Lavender for sensitive skin. I read that as two different creams, hence the different ratings.
Actually, the list is a little odd. At AOS's website, their Lavender is listed as for sensitive skin. No Lavender, and Lavender for Sensitive Skin. I actually took #46 as saying the Lemon for All Skin Types shaving cream has a rating of 4. Just like #47 says it does, except in travel size.
I got some samples of Art of Shaving because it ranked fairly well and is fairly widely available. Though it takes a bit more time to build up a lather (e.g. 20 seconds longer), I've very happy with it. It's a good compromise between trying to find something totally non-toxic and organic AND is a good cream that is easy to find.
+1 on TBS Maca Root. Got one from my wife for Christmas and it has become my new go-to shave cream, replacing my TOBS Lemon & Lime. Great lather!
This looks like a very interesting option. I would love to hear from anyone that's used it extensively. As far as a TOM replacement, Kiss My Face is excellent.