I have both SDM and EM. I have had EM for some time and love it. Use it often in the rotation. SDM I have only used twice. A recent acquisition. I'm not sure about the scent of SDM. Maybe it will grow on me. For what it is worth - I have several other Stirling soaps. Of those, Barbershop and Bay Rum are probably my most frequently used soaps. Both are great and work well with my hard well water.
you still have your Stirling Clubman even though it's discontinued now? That's my situation with my Rise Super Foam AND the Rise Aftershave Cooling Balm(Raffle prize #17). Both are gone from the company, but I still have 5 Super Foams, and I think 7 or 8 Cooling Balms.
You could probably auction those Clubman pucks off for a small fortune. There was a pretty interesting conversation about it on the AMA Rod did on Reddit.