So I have always been a cream guy I have tried soap in the past but it was not good for my skin. I recently tried super lather with a sample of Con. Conk's lime and it worked great. Now I know you soap guys are very forceful and opinionated so well whats a good unscented soap.
I haven't tried many. Unscented is growing on me as I get bored of scents. Mitchells Wool Fat is my best so far.
Mama Bear, Honeybee Spa, and Susie's Bubble's all make great unscented soaps. Mitchell's Wool Fat and Institut Karite both have a light scent and are superb soaps (my top two).
Scented soaps are nice but it's the performance of the soap that counts. I've found that my aftershaves and colognes are much more important scent-wise.
I've tried a few and, for me, the pick of the (almost) unscented is Provence Sante. Great lather and very moisturizing. Their after shave is absurdly good too - unless you need your alcohol zing. Cheers Jeremy