Im looking to get a soap that comes as close as possible to the old Old Spice scent. I know Stirling and Mama Bears makes them. Is there any other maker? Which one comes the closest to the old scent?
Prairie Creations. I bought some 3 or 4 years ago and it is top notch soap. Disregard. I just checked her site and the Old Spice is no longer listed so she apparently has stopped making that scent.
I use Van Der Hagen Luxury Unscented. It's a good soap even in hard water. I add a few dribbles of Old Spice (either original or the new stuff) to the top of the puck and let it sit while I'm showering. I've also used Family Dollar imitation Old Spice. The scent is there for the shave and you can use the same puck of soap another day dribbling something different on top (like The Veg!) or just keep adding Old Spice.
Well I just ordered from Stirling, their Ozark Mountain got me curious too lol. Now I have two pucks to try out I think I need to stop buying, already have 12 types of soaps and creams.
Some say artisan Calani from Germany makes an awesom Old Spice soap. I have yet to try it, but I'm going to!
Well, I was going to suggest the Stirling Spice, but I see you have some on the way. It is excellent. I would also try some of the original Shulton Old Spice Cream. I used mine again this morning.
