I tend to change it up daily. Somedays I try to marry up with a cologne, some days I let the aftershave scent stand on it's own. I've been using an assortment from Fine Accoutrements lately. I do have to admit.... I love the ones that BURN.
Below is what I use. Although I just ordered a bottle of Cella after shave. It hasn't arrived yet. No set rotation - just use what I feel like that day - same as I do for my soaps. I also use a balm, especially this time of year with the air being dry. None of these three balms have much of a scent. I put the balm on first and let it get absorbed into the skin and then apply a splash of after shave.