Island Man is by far my favorite of the Sterling scents. Executive Man, Mountain Man and Sharp Dressed Man are great too. My wife gives Island Man and Executive Man a big thumbs up! I enjoy Sterling Green, having grown up during the hayday of the Polo scent, but my wife is not a real fan. If you haven't tried their bath soaps, they are absolutely fabulous. You won't want to go back to regular bath bars after you try them!
Just received a great PIF from @whiteboy_cannon of Stirling Glacial wintergreen soap and matching post shave balm. Never used any Stirling products before so I'm excited to give them a try. Ken P.
I haven't yet tried it, but I was impressed by its description and some reviews. A good outdoorsy scent, perhaps best to use in the fall. I'm not ruling it out as a future purchase.
There are so many great stirling soaps that it's hard to choose the best. I recommend having a couple fir each season. I like margaritas in the artic and iced pineapple for the summer. Executive man and sharp dressed man are good year round.