My thoughts exactly.

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

Green Mountain and D. R. Harris

Sent from my LG-H820 using Tapatalk

I have my first Beef Tallow from Stirling, thanks to a generous PIFer.

Arko Shaving Stick
Haslinger Schafmilch Sheep Milk & Lanolin (very similar to MWF)
La Toja Shaving Stick
Mitchell's Wool Fat
Pre De Provence No. 63
Stirling Shaving Soap
Tabac

L&L with the Bison Tallow has climbed right up there with SMN V.3 and Nuavia for me

mickey lee's and stirling

What, no love for Cella?

MWF is one of my very favorites also. Around $15 for a puck that is triple milled and will lasts well over 9 months. I really like the subtle scent and I find it extremely easy to lather. The point that puts it over the top for me is what it does to my face. It is like magic the way it protects and heals. Shannon's soaps are right up there too but a softer soap that doesn't last as long. Shannons does have a nice selection of scents though.

Cella is another great tallow soap and in the 1K brick is very affordable!

Stirling
Tabac
Cella
MWF

Vintage Williams from either the Glastonbury or Cranford plants.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Hands down, Cella. I have gone through 2 kilo bricks of that wonderful soap. I have my technique zeroed in where I can produce thick, yogurt-y, protective, and slick lather with ease. And it leaves my face feeling amazing afterwards.

Although, Stirling is a serious contender. I've only tried their unscented version and was blown away with the performance.

I am, and will forever be a Stirling man. They are on my Mount Rushmore, and I don't ever see them coming down.
I do have to add that I generally get a better lather out of Barrister and Mann, but I have only used Seville, and received night music in the mail the other day (I haven't used that one yet). The only problem is it seem like along with limited options as far as scents they are very much an acquired taste. I a wanting to do a full fledged posting about this, but just haven't gotten around to it yet. Need to do that sometime this weekend.

Make mine Stirling also, please!

I'll add Stirling Clubman to my prior list.

Stirling hasn't made Clubman in quite some time. I know, because I keep checking to see if they bring it back.

That's a shame, isn't it?

I am not familiar with Green Mountain, but I ridded my den of all my DRH, except the Arlington Cream.

Yea, I am really wanting it in the aftershave form. It really is something to take an iconic product, and improve it. I like pinaud clubman, but to me when I first put it on it is very skunky, and ever once in a while I pick up on it. I don't know if it is just me or if I have a bad batch.

Mystic Waters & panna Crema

Stirling soap, Barrister and Mann, Mickey Lee Soap Works

They are some of my top soaps regardless of ingredients or price.