Tabac!

I also really like Provence Sante Verlaine and Speick A/S.

As for balms... I'm still searching for one that I can call amazing.

I tend to lean towards balms. I don't have sensitive skin, but I prefer soothing over burning.

I am a big fan of GFT Skin Food (Limes or Coral).

Prior to discovering those I normally used Nivea ASB.

Same here! I want that sting of alcohol after my shave!

My singlemost #1 choice: Proraso Green Splash!

I've recently added SCS aftershave milks to my favorites list...

Balm- Weleda and Proraso

Splash- Speick by default, I haven't tried any other splashes.

Then you must love Pinaud Bay Rum.

Aqua Velva

Skin Bracer Cool Spice

Another AV user! Welcome to the club!

Favorites are
SCS Mediterranean Citrus Splash
Favorite balms
SCS Avocado Oil
SCS Nutriment

If it was still around it would be Aqua Velva Lime.

As it is not, then the one and only D.R. Harris Pink!

In no particular order:
Skin Bracer by Mennen
Aqua Velva Classic
Old Spice
British Sterling
Avon Black Suede (have 5 bottles, the Avon Lady treats me well!)

Favorites: Dominica bay Rum and Pinaud Clubman Classic.
"It don't mean a thing if it don't have that sting."
dannyr

Pairing it up hits the spot.

Musgo Real Cream and A/S
Tabac Soap or Cream and A/S
Ogallala Bay Rum Soap and A/S

Balms

Burt's Bees Natural
My own blend of hand lotion, thayers wh, grapeseed oil, and some EO
Aubrey Organics Island Spice

Splashes

Dominica Bay Rum
Anything Thayers
Aubrey Organics Island Spice

You do know that Aqua Velva opened as a mouthwash(probably a Listerine clone), right?

Splashes-Clubman
Skin-Bracer
Stephan Bay Rum

Balms-Rise Cooling

Yep; It's Mennen After Shave! (Original)

WOW!! 6-1/2 year old thread!!!
That's some serious diggin'!!

Since he hasn't been participating or seen at TSD for over 5 years, I fear your question may remain unanswered.....