If you could only have one soap and one scent, what would it be?

I haven't tried enough to choose from. I hope this thread becomes as popular as SOTD and YO!, so I'll be able to answer.

 

I am sorry to hear that. Makes me sad when a Williams guy is missing out. Heat some bottled water.

 

Overall, I have some pedestrian tastes when it comes to shaving.

The Arko Shave Stick is inexpensive and works like a champ. For an added aftershave, when I use it, Superior 70 is my choice. It works well, has a nice light scent that dissipates pretty quickly and is inexpensive.

 

Icoloniali


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

It's all good.
MdC is one of those polarizing scents where some love it and others simply can't abide it. Sort of like the Veg scent...except the Veg does truly stink.

 

Arko works fine in my water, so I go with that instead.

 

Tabac, superior performance and the scent is pleasant enough. And if I did not like the scent I could cover it up with TSD Barber shoppe after shave.

Dave

 

Nuavia Rosso. It's expensive upfront, but I know my jar will outlive me. And the scent is by far the most sophisticated among the soaps I have. Except perhaps the Nuavia Blu.

 

Tabac is another great choice, Dave.

 

But that's 2. We're talkinabout something you can't cover up. (Or as Winston would have said, "up with which you can't cover").

 

I could smell Fine American Blend everyday for the rest of my life. So i guess that's my ONE.

 

OK, you got me. From this day forward I will only use something like witch hazel or Lucky Tiger after I shave with Tabac. Or maybe I will order some Tabac after shave.

Dave

 

Whew, good to hear that. Now we don't have march 10 paces and using sling shots to fire an alum block at each other. My eyes are not what they used to be. The fun part of this is I really don't get too wound up about soap scents. By time I am done with rinsing my face, there is not much scent left.

Dave

 

my apologies-I see I didn't quite follow your post. This "one soap" thing is tricky.

 

...well, I see you slang a shot at me.....replying just as I deleted!!

 

Don't apologize, Just have fun with it. Beside, I don't have an alum block now. have to order one next time I order Tabac soap.

Dave

 

Never heard of the alum block...what's it all about?

 

It is like this one from RazoRock. I rub it on my face after I shave and it stop any little weepers I may have caused. If my shave is particularly close, the stinging will set me free. But, sadly I dropped my alum block in the sink and it shattered into 100 pieces.


Dave

 

Tough question for me to answer.

But I think my answer would have to be Panna Crema.

 

I guess MWF.