I've seen a bunch of threads where everyone shares their favorite Stirling scents, and plenty of lists of everyone's favorites from Razorock, Fine, and PAA, but what about Wet Shaving Products? I only have the Sandalwood and I love it. It lasts a long time, it is simple sandalwood without other florals or sweets competing. I also feel that it works very well as an aftershave, leaving a nice post shave feel to the skin. I think it is time to add another bottle, but which scent?

I match your comments, as Sandalwood is all I have for now. I HOPE it lasts a long time, as I think it'll be gone long before the Sandalwood soap I have(also from WSP). I like it too. Lee focuses on MANLINESS with his arsenal. I had my eye on the Matterhorn for my next one, but am seeing positive reports on the Mahogony.

Blackbeard is my favorite WSP scent.

I was thinking Matterhorn, too, and Summer Breeze, and Gaelic Tweed, and Tobacco...

Gaelic Tweed sounds similar to Stirling's Sharp Dressed Man.

I shaved with the Mahogany SS tonight, I really like it.

Clayton

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk

I've tried both Stirling Sharp Dressed Man and WSP Gaelic Tweed just in the past week.

WSP is a bit smoother scent, very close to GIT. Masculine and understated come to mind.

Stirling is a much stronger scent, though still very reminiscent of GIT.

Me, I prefer the scent of Stirling Sharp Dressed Man even though it doesn't agree with my skin. WSP is a VERY close second, though. Both are wonderful scents, can't go wrong either way.

This is a scent I've wanted to try.

Really nice smell and quality lather.

MAHOGANY - only WSP has it and it's absolutely fantastic!

Hmm interested in mahogany

My too is tobacco.
Runner up. Barbercool.
Matterhorn

I have a number of WSP soap and aftershave, I just can't get into them, the aftershaves leave me feeling like a giant slimmer hit me.

I have the Barbershop and Mahogany, of which I prefer the Mahogany. It is one of my wife's favorites as well, so that probably skews my opinion.

I ended up getting the Gaelic Tweed so now I have that and the Sandalwood. Neither gives me a slimy feeling. I will say that the Gaelic seems to dry a little faster than the Sandalwood. I have several Stirling aftershaves and some of those seem to dry faster than others, too, but no slimy feeling. Gaelic smells great by the way, if you like a classic cologne type scent.

I only have one and that's barbershop. I think it's a great scent and would like to get the splash as well.

Sent from my SM-N920V using Tapatalk

Like their Lavender, Barbershop, Drakkar like scent and their Black Orchid.

Traded off the sandalwood as it didn't agree with my nose at all.

1. Gaelic Tweed
2. Matterhorn
3. Ol' Kentucky
4. Mahogany
5. Barbershop

My top four

1. Matterhorn
2.blackbeard
3. Mahogany
4. Galiec Tweed

I also have tried barbershop and tobacco. It's okay just not my favorite. Hated tobacco smelled like straight up basil to me. Couldnt get over it

My five WSP scents in order of appreciation...

1. Blackbeard
2. Black Amber Vanille
3. Gaelic Tweed
4. Vetiver
5. Citrus Blast