I would go with Stirling, I think. With the disclaimer that I haven't smelled Stirling agar, and that could change my answer.
I have the AoS Oud, Stirling Agar and King of Oud and all 3 are good performers for me. The AoS is a cream and the scent of this one seems to stick around the longest. I don't have any Oud scented AS. It's a scent I enjoy.
Ouds and Roses are my bag... As mentioned above WK King of Oud, Van Yulay Royal Oudh . Combing my two favorite scents CBL Black Rose Oud and Eufros Rosa-Oud
I recently finished a tin of SV 70th anniversary edition and tried this soap (based on this post). I was impressed. TFS soaps are right up there among my favorites and this one was another excellent soap from them. At under $8 for a tub, it's a bargain. I'm not an authority on oud scents, but this scent was pleasant without overpowering. Performance was typical of a TFS soap, easy to lather, cushioning and slick. Thanks for the tip.
Has anyone tried the Club-Signature?? This one is Sandalwood and Oud many have said its amazing. Looking for a more in-depth review. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I have a final test version, which is very close to the AS that was released after. Definitely a nice scent, one of my favorite Stirling scents.
Lisa’s has a limited release oud soap coming out this month. I’ll bet it’s good because she hasn’t made a bad soap that I’ve tried and I’ve tried many.
Actually, this thread is helping ME, as I need a good Oud AFTERSHAVE for my Lumberjack soap(Soap Exchange).
I think Agarwood/Oud and Leather will be my gradual "turn-to" scents. (Not that I am forgoing others).