Need a little help figuring out which orangey soaps to get aftershave or EDT for. I just tried out 3 orangey samples: piacenza, arkadia, and pharoah's dreamsicle. At first whiff and useage I thought I liked arkadia and pharoah's dreamsicle's scents the best. Then this morning I used piacenza and it was just as excellent. What I usually like to do is purchase EDT for the scents I like the absolute best, possibly aftershave if I like it a lot, and maybe just blow off the mediocre or least liked. I'm already putting together another Stirling order up here in Canada that tentatively included some tsuka and orange chill. Long story short, I realized that makes about 5 orangey soap/aftershaves, etc. If I ever get Satsuma, 6! I probably only need or could practically use maybe 3 of those (or 4?). Then there's always the possibility on 1 or 2 of those, a single aftershave could double up on a similar scent as well as its own matched scent. I'm just going around in circles trying to figure it all out. Maybe I'm an orangey kinda guy and didn't realize it. Since you guys are prob more familiar with each of these, could some of you chip in with input and help a brother decide? It'd be much appreciated. Also could save my wife from killing me if she saw I ordered 5 or 6 orange aftershaves!
Beginning tomorrow, 5 straight uses of Stoylin aftershaves happening(2 with 1 shave, 3 for another). I'll clarify this confusion in SOTD.
Oh yeah, they’re a terrific bunch of guys and their stuff is awesome. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Piacenza is a dupe of a century old Italian citrus unisex scent that’s stood the test of time pretty well. There are other dupes of the same scent, so it’s popular. Arkadia’s musk notes make a bolder statement, and create a faster love/hate reaction IMO, though it’s a dupe of a legendary French scent. The Dreamsicle scent has a good vanilla element to it that may place it above Piacenza depending on your nose or mood. I really like it, but I usually like the vanilla notes in various scents whether citrus or tobacco or oud, etc. Of the three I’d eliminate Arkadia if you can only buy two.
Can anyone tell the difference between the regular soaps and the glacial one's? A google search i only found out that it's a sort of clay that they add? Verstuurd vanaf mijn GM1913 met Tapatalk
Glacial soaps contain a high level of menthol. Chill or Iced soaps have a medium level of menthol and regular soaps have no menthol. Besides the methol the soap base is the same.
And an update on that plan...I'll be using the Unscented Friday, with the hopes that the soap scent will still come through. If not, I do have backup(which won't be Stoylin).
I got that "tingle" with the Spice aftershave-lasted about a half-hour and has now settled down. The aftershave will finish long before the soap, but how many times have I said THAT in here....1....2...47??
Ehhh Ladies and uh Gentlemen: I'll be ordering my "Runner-Up" from the last Tony before summer hits.....Lime A.S.(Glacial if possible)and Mtn, Man Liquid Bodywash.
Posting well after this shave, but better late than never. Followed up my Variant reacquaintance shave with a similar using the newest addition to the Max Headroom Shave Gear collection. The featured hardware is the popular Gillette Slim Adjustable I won in the Raffle as generously donated by @Tommynick. Thank you Tommy. Software by Stirling, and from The Max Headroom List of Most Glorious Stanks, Island Man. Fluffed up an easy lather with the collapsible paddle bowl and went to the face at the prescribed setting of 9 with a new Personna Blue. Made the pattern adjustments dictated on my last shave and walked away happy. This is my first shave with a Gillette Adjustable TTO. I find it easily conforms to 'ride the cap' training for great cutting but it left me missing the blade feel and audible feedback offered by the Variant. For me it is not an 'either/or', it is just yes. Edison Carter reporting for Network XXIII, now blipvert free thanks to The Rebus Tape.
Guess I'm such an idiot couldn't figure out how to post a screenshot, but here's some Stirling I ordered today up in Canada (whoopsie, might've went overboard a little hehe): Soap samples: MITA Orange Chill Stirling Blu Stirling Noir Stirling Gentleman 3 oz Shave Soap: Tsuka Stirling Green 2 oz A/S Splash: Tsuka 100 ml A/S Splash: Ozark Mountain Baker Street Arkadia 50 ml EDT: Sandpiper Pharoah's Dreamsicle Island Man EMP Plus they owed me an unscented Menthol Post Shave Balm from the last order. Feeling pretty good about it. At least now I'll have a little more closely matched aftershaves or EDT's to the soaps
Nice haul. Excellent choices. I need to get me some tsuka and try it. Everybody is so ranting about that soap/scent. Verstuurd vanaf mijn GM1913 met Tapatalk
Paul, order some samples of the Lemon Chill, and the Lime SS if you don't have it all ready. I cut the samples in half and combine them side by side in my Old Spice mug. I layer the samples two deep so both samples are used. There is nothing better than super mentholated lemon/lime shaving lather. Clayton Sent from my SM-A705U using Tapatalk
