What is your favorite shave soap? No creams, no sticks, no caned goo, soaps only please.

Williams....If I just had one that would be it. Simple effective cheap..

Van Der Hagen Glycerine Shave Soap... Use it most every day... But MWF, which I have only used once is VERY nice.

one vote for wiliams one for van der hagen.

Van Der Hagen Deluxe -- combines the best properties of the Select and the Glycerin. Williams is in second place.

Williams, hands down. Great soap at 89 cents a puck and it smells nice too.

Two votes each and I am going to say why I ask.

I have a puck of Mama Bear Ylang Ylang that I don't like the scent at all. I am going to need to buy a new shave bowl shortly and I am thinking of what to fill the bowl with.

Tabac for me. Although I have some Irisch Moos coming in, so that might change

+1. Or colgate, if you can find it.

Interesting Williams takes the lead. 3 Williams, 2 Van Der Hagen and a Tabac.

Susies Bubbles olive oil based Dragon's Blood

TSD soaps, my personal favorite is Bourbon Vanilla.

Hmm, might order a TSD soap.

Tabac for me...easy lather smooth shave and pretty inexpensive.

3 Williams, 2 Van Der Hagen, 2 Williams a Susie's and a TSD. Williams still wins thus far but the Van Der Hagen is interesting.

Boy, am I glad you excluded that!

another Williams fan here...Tabac a close second.

Truefitt and Hill Luxury soap for me

Wool Fat. How has no one suggest Wool Fat?

Em's line of soaps -- great lathering and skin care.