Rose without a doubt. Almond's second-best. TOBS does a similar Almond. The line's Rose is pretty close too, but not as good.
TH the way to go The one scent you will not try in sampler pack is Rose. I ordered a sampler and it didn't come with it, but everything else did. The best scents I like is 1805. I wished they made Freshmen into shaving cream, awesome scent! Followed by Trafalgar and Grafton. I don't Truefitt and Hill makes awesome shaving products. If you like one of the major scents a lot, you can buy triple milled soap, bath and shower gel and couple other things in the same scent. Even their Almond is really good.
Grafton and Trafalgar with the nod going to Grafton. I like 1805 and lime as well but Grafton is my choice scent behind MdC Fougere
I just received my T&H Grafton and am so far disappointed in the scent, finding it too green or fruity upon applying and lingering on those notes. Finally after over 2 hours it settled into something I could tolerate, that soapy fragrance I was looking for. I'll give it a few more test runs before making a final decision.
Grafton was my first favorite T&H scent. Interesting enough, despite its popularity, I didn’t think much of 1805 but eventually came to appreciate it. These days I have a full stable of T&H products. Great stuff. Give the Grafton some time or set it aside for a few months and come back to it.