1. Funny, I can't really come up with a worst smelling AS. I like some a lot better than others but I'll wear just about anything including Lilac Vegetal, Lime Sec, Old Spice, English Leather, etc. I must say though, I'm not a big fan of Skin Bracer. When it first came out I jumped on the bandwagon and stayed there for a couple years. I guess I just burned myself out on it.
  2. I agree.
  3. Irena, the smell of Stetson gives me a headache, and I get nauseous. Oufffffff, it's disgusting. :( :sick007
  4. I go through stages with Aqua Velva - I'm enjoying it these days, but there have been times when I'd rather dip my head in battery acid.

    Most days, though, I just reach for the Proraso A/S splash.

    If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

    goshawk
  5. Folks,

    I remember some "after shaves" by Avon in the early 60's that were pretty disgusting! :sick007 I hope they have improved! I'll have to ask a friend who is actually an Avon lady!
  6. My wife recently bought me some Black Suede by Avon. Not a front runner by a long shot but a decent functional AS balm and cologne.
  7. Pinaud Vegetal I find is the worst smelling AF. I like Proraso AF lotion
  8. whoa nelly! they make aftershaves? who buys their stuff anyway? I have never heard of anyone enjoying an Herban Cowboy product.
  9. Hi Karate !
  10. Whoops!

    I like anything that has the old fashioned barbershop smell...

    :D
  11. Not technically an AS, but I suppose some people use it as such... anyway, I can't understand how anyone in their right mind decided to bottle 4711.
    I think its just awful.
  12. There is a 4711 AS, and I like both it and the cologne's scent
  13. I do too. Reminds me of my dad who is no longer around.

  14. Irena, leider habe ich dieses Aftershave probiert. Jedoch, ist das Koelnischwasser sehr angenehm!
  15. Ja, es ist angenehm.
  16. PM me your address and I'll PIF you a great, big, vile smelling bottle of it. :sick007
  17. Irena, jemand erzaehlte mir, dass es ein Koelnischwasser von 4711 mit Menthol gibt. Ich habe es nie gesehen, aber ich moechte es bekommen! :) :drool
  18. Menthol ist einer interessanten Hinzufügung ähnlich. Ich habe es auch nicht gesehen.
  19. The Bad Few

    For me, Pinaud Vegetal and Master Iceland Breeze are the worst. I enjoy most all others at least a little, except for these two. :(
  20. Pinaud LV would be my choice. I tried to like it but just couldn't bring myself around.