Great, cheap and underrated are - in my opinion - Italian soaps, like Proraso (pre and post, shaving soap (tube and ciotola) and their cream and splas as) Other great soap is Figaro and Crema Cella, where the figaro is really a bargain for the kilo of great scent you get.
VDH Deluxe (or Glycerin) shave soap fit the bill totally, as does Aqua Velva Classic. IMHO both products (although very affordable and widely available) consistently deliver fantastic quality.
+1 Those are both affordable products that just work, and work well. One does not need fancy products to get a great shave.
CANNED FOAM !!! just kidding! :happy102 Best would be KMF (my pref is Lavender, but the others are also excellent) with Ivy Club Pour Hommes (Vi-Jon's Spice aftershave -- Shulton OS knock-off) for a follow-up. :signs097
original Barbasol IMHO. probably raising tons of eyebrows here, but what can I say? I've tried Nivea, Gillette, Old Spice, etc. price/quality-wise Barbasol beats 'em for me. part of it is traveling - I used to live in/travel around Europe frequently and Barbasol was a very inexpensive companion. yes, the can rusts after a few months but the dispenser is plastic, so it's not like you're shaving with brown foam on your face
Some really good, underrated creams are: Florena, Speick, Nivea. Soaps: Speick stick, Palmolive stick Really great value for the money
I agree with Tiberiu. Also, let me add another fantastic and probably underrated cream, which is Solo Menthol. I don't know if it is cheap or expensive, but it is wonderful.
Master's Shaving Soap Here's a soap that gets bad reviews that I happen to like- Master's Shaving Soap. My barber gave me a few pucks when I told him about my new hobby. It's about $12 for 8 pucks. It's very easy to to lather up and has a nice soapy smell-just my idea what soap should smell like-I'm not very good with the descriptive adjectives. Somebody on BB said it smells like the puck used in a urinal-no way.
I agree, but that doesn't bother me, it just means a generous hit of Iced Subzero AS Milk when I'm thru. As long as I don't get dried out I don't mind using some extra AS, it's about lather and protection for me.
I like these, cost under 2 Dollars for both. They work very well. I'm going to get a stock before the supermarket stops selling them.