Forums Register login New Posts
Bay Rum Aftershave Splash or Cream
  1. HOUS3Y
    So, in trying different shaving soaps, I have discovered that I love the Bay Rum scent. I have seen many different ASs online and am trying to decide which to purchase. First what is your preference, splash or cream AS? And, secondly what brand of Bay Rum do you prefer? It is all very overwhelming for a newbie and I don't want to waste a lot of money trying things that haven't been proven.

    Thanks in advance,
    Scott
  2. Williams Warrior
    Captain's Choice and Dominica are the two best smelling IMO. I've never seen a Bay Rum balm before though.
    HOUS3Y likes this.
  3. Ryan B
    Krampert's Bay Rum gets a lot of high praises. I can only speak for Krampert's Frostbite, but it's in my top 5 aftershaves.
    HOUS3Y likes this.
  4. drew23
    I can say that I really like the Frostbite as well. I have the Bay Rum but just received it last week so, I can't comment on it. Not sure if I can get the wife passed on the BR but, I'm trying.
    HOUS3Y and Tdmsu like this.
  5. Bobcat
    I like the Krampert's Bay Rum Acadian Spice. It has both a great Bay Rum scent and great conditioning.

    [​IMG]
    ObiDon, HOUS3Y and Tdmsu like this.
  6. Dave Paskowski
    Pinaud Clubman - Virgin Island BAY RUM
    HOUS3Y likes this.
  7. drew23
    Looks like a good setup to me.
    HOUS3Y likes this.
  8. Tdmsu
    Krampert's Finest Bay Rum is excellent, both for scent and skin conditioning, IMHO.
    I just got Frostbite this afternoon, and I tried it - another winner!
    HOUS3Y likes this.
  9. Queen of Blades
    I've seen Bay Rum aftershave milk. ;)
    HOUS3Y, Williams Warrior and Ryan B like this.
  10. Littlemax
    Prefer a splash. Pinaud VIBR my favorite.
    Dave Paskowski likes this.
  11. frankflood
    I use the Ogallala line of Bay Rums but maybe time to go out on a limb with something different? Captain's doesn't really float my boat but I use it to have it be gone from the room. Krampert's maybe?
  12. Cool Breeze
    I love the original clubman but have yet to find a woman who doesn't find it apalling, including my wife.
  13. Dave Paskowski
    My wife doesn't like it. That's why I use it.:bounce015:
    Richard Jackson, Cool Breeze, HOUS3Y and 1 other person like this.
  14. HolyRollah
    I prefer creams and balms over most aftershaves.
    For Bay rum, of the commercial varieties, I like the Ogallala product (fav is Bay Rum with Lime & Peppercorn). I also use my homemade 'BlackRiver' bay rum, which is a bit milder than most store-bought brands, which my wife prefers.
    [​IMG]
    ObiDon, Tdmsu, HOUS3Y and 1 other person like this.
  15. Ryan B
    That is such a cool bottle. You get bonus "cool" points for using a cork as a lid.
  16. HOUS3Y
    Do you sell this homemade Bay Rum, by any chance?
  17. HolyRollah
(You have insufficient privileges to reply here.)