1.] Aqua Velva Blue 2.] PVIBR 3.] Family Dollar Vi-Jon Spice 4.] Osage Rub

In no particular order.

Williams Ice Blue (that's AV for the US people)

Old Spice Original

Nivea for Men Sensitive asb.

Edit: The Old Spice is more expensive than 10bucks to I guess I have to take it off the list.

1 Floid blue
2 Floid blue
3 Floid blue

Sure, almost 30 euro's, but what you get is 400 ml....

Superior 70 or Stephens Bay Rum
M&L Florida Water
Clubman Vanilla

Old Spice. My number one, and still is.
Don't know if you can get it now, or what it costs, but I used to like British Sterling a lot.
Yeah, here it is, but it breaks the limit by .88 cents.
http://www.walmart.com/ip/British-Sterling-Men-s-After-Shave-3.8-fl-oz/10315323
Brut

Dollar General's Brut knockoff
Aqua Velva Musk
Afta lotion (it's been on clearance all around my area...I wonder if it's dying)

I'd have to say:
1) Old Spice
2) Pinaud Clubman - just recently tried this for the first time and love it.
3) Aqua Velva Musk

I have tons of different aftershaves. And only one cost more than $10, Captains Choice North.

Narrowing the others down to 3 favorites is very tough for me but here goes:
#1 - Skin Bracer
#2 - Vintage Avon - Tai Winds
#3 - Lilac Vegetal

And honorable mention to a homemade concoction: Bootlegger's Bay Rum.

Clubman pinaud, master bay rum and oak and agave. Florida water is pretty awesome too.

Denim,Old Spice,Brut,Barbon

Dove, Nivea, Axe (yes, really). And, let's not forget plain old Hydrogen Hydroxide.

Just smells that way.

They have a lilac version?

Does anyone know if all Dollar Generals have stopped carrying the Old Spice knockoff? The only place I see it now is CVS, but their prices are always jacked and they want $5.50 for a bottle of the stuff. I wouldn't pay that even for actual Old Spice.

found this one for 1.07

I don't know if Dollar General carries it. I bought the Family Dollar Spice for $2, it's the Family Dollar knockoff.

I've almost always just stuck with my ol' standby, witch-hazel & alcohol. Mostly because nothing else seems to feel as good on or be as good for good for my face. Obviously, it's still only about a couple of bucks for 16 ounces (I just mix the witch-hazel & alcohol about 2:1).

Pinaud Clubman
Aqua Velva

Or

Unscented generic witch hazel

Pinaud Clubman
Pinaud Musk
Aqua Velva Ice blue