Well, I read a little article on TAOM yesterday and after seeing the Lone Ranger Aqua Velva commercial I was sold. I just had to get me some Old School Aftershave. That menthol tingle felt so good, but I definitely want to try others. I am waiting on you Jeff (CrackStar).
Barbon Krampert's Frostbite Fine Aftershave. All those have menthol. Stirling Witch Hazel Myrsol Emulsion Floid Blue
Mennen Original Skin Bracer is a classic "old School" menthol after shave. Good, cheap and available; hard to beat.
Any one you have or like that's not mentholated. Buy some M-Bomb from TSD store, add as much or little to suit your taste. And while your shopping pick up some menthol crystals. And remember, all purchases pay to keep our home away from home up and running..
OK Mark - here are some of my favourites. Let's start with: 1) Osage Rub (aka the Rubby Dubby Doo - BRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!!!!!) 2) Barbon (great scent, very cold, wonderful skincare) 3) Mennen Skin Bracer 4) Aqua Velva Ice Blue 5) Floid Classic (cold, with a powdery scent - very nice) 6) Alt Innsbruck (very cold with a lovely scent) 7) Alcolado Glacial (not really an aftershave, but you can use it as one and it's frigidly-cold)
Krampert's Frostbite is excellent. Cold but also cares for the skin, so if you'd like some care with the kick...
I've been using Osage Rub more than ever, this week. Oddly, I've always been pretty neutral on menthol until now.
Wow, there is a lot of cold stuff across the ocean. Here I can get overpriced proraso green and L'oreal. Nivea has one or two with a cool kick but they are not sold in Sweden which is weird. Maybe it's because we just need to go outside for that cold =P
The Osage is king. And don't forget the TSD M-Bomb-makes COLD anywhere (lather, AS, etc). Here are some others not mentioned that are decent: Barbasol Brisk Master Blue Proraso After Shave Lotion