I used each of these soaps per pass on my Monday morning shave:
Texas on Fire (WTG) - I lathered it the same way that I've been lathering the other Stirling soaps with the same results. I enjoy this smell, but this seems to be more of a novelty scent. I can't identify all the different scents in this, but basically it smells like a combination of campfire, the remains in a pipe after being smoked, and a bit of leather. I have every intention of using ToF when I go to our camp house for a weekend fishing or hunting trip. I'd also use it just hanging around the house, but this isn't something that I would wear to work, a business meeting, on a date, etc. While I prefer strong scents, campfire smoke isn't the scent I want to project in those type settings. Did I mention that this scent is really strong? I had to rinse my hands off thoroughly, twice, to get the smoke scent off (so I could smell the other 2 Stirling scents that I was about to try). That isn't a bad thing either! I simply didn't want that scent interacting with the other two Stirling scents I was about to try. I have allergies and asthma, so it was particularly nice for me to be able to smell smoke without coughing up a lung. Same great shave as with the other Stirling shave soaps that I have used.
Nag Champa (XTG) - I got this sample puck as a free sample included in my order. I have been pleasantly surprised by this scent. It definitely has a soapy smell, but also another scent that I can't quite place (without googling). This scent is clean and is stronger than other soapy scents I have smelled. It is bugging me what the other scent(s) in this are but whatever they are, I will definitely order a full puck of this in the near future. There were no noticeable issues going from ToF to Nag Champa while shaving XTG.
Lavender Sage (ATG & Touch Ups) - This scent popped once I took it out of the shrink wrap. I'm not sure why, but something about this reminds of grapefruit/pink lemonade in addition to the floral scents. The scent remained strong during lathering and application. I've never smelled "Lavender Sage" before and have no idea what the scent is supposed to be. All I know is that I like this scent. The scent died down a little during lathering but it was certainly still present during the shave. I don't know if I'll order a full puck of this or just order a sample puck here and there when I place other orders.
**Maybe I don't have enough experience to tell, but so far I haven't noticed any differences in any of the Stirling soaps regarding lather, slickness, and how it makes my face feel toned and moisturized. **
Scents I hate (although I'm sure the product performs as well as others):
Clubman - I couldn't bring myself to put this on my face. To me, it smelled like Catfish Stink Bait. I didn't even get a hint of "Clubman" or anything pleasant. YMMV, so don't let what I think smells bad turn you away. I was expecting something that smelled like Pinaud Clubman, so this very well could be one of those I just had the wrong expectation and couldn't get past it not matching. I wound up trashing the puck without lathering it on my face or shaving with it.
Glacial Obsidian - I can't even bring myself to take this out of the wrapping, much less put it anywhere on my body. I was hoping that aversion to black licorice had subsided. I was also hoping that the "soap" part would maybe tone down that wretched smell that makes me want to yack. Nope, no such luck for Dubs. It literally made me nauseated to smell. I might as well lather with Nyquil, or at least use Nyquil as an aftershave with its almost perfect scent match.

Click to expand...