Clubman may indeed have a burning sensation, but I don't mind that, as I use it only during the cool/cold months.
For an aftershave with the perfect amount of menthol and fantastic fragrance...you can't beat Proraso Splash! That's my go to summer splash. In the winter I'm in love with Speick for it's skin care. No menthol in it though.
Sandalo 1800 smells great, don't get next to an open flame for a bit. better figure on using a balm also. but you won't have germs and you'll smell good.
I'm pretty sure @Queen of Blades makes a Sandalwood skin milk. I can't check it right now, as the TSD Shop has "Bandwidth Limit Exceeded" sign up right now. That would be what I recommend.
I'm also a big fan of Sandalwood as well as mint. I just ordered the Stirling Sandalwood soap and balm. Any others I should look at? Going to get the TSD spearmint as well. Thought I'd contribute to the cause!!
I really enjoy Captain's Choice. They have a great sandalwood. I pair it with Nivea Sensitive aftershave balm which doesn't have a scent really.