In order of preference... Green, red, white.

Can not say for certain except New advertising states "Contains no parabens, silicons, mineral oils or artificial colours"

I used the red this morning and I've come to the realization that I need to stock up on more. Is it still NB 16?

That's like stocking up on Budweiser. It will still be around next year.

The Green was my first (ever) soap, so I still hold a certain fondness for it. Probably shave with it once a month or so.

I've had some of my best shaves with the Green. Haven't tried the others yet. The performance fell off toward the end of the tub though. I need to buy some more!

I so agree I'm lightweight... I tried Ingram some time ago - it literally hurt my face, like, not that pleasant! And it ain’t even in the league of some of the true face-freezer soaps used here....

But when I use Green regularly, I don't detect the wild freeze either. But it's there - it's just not that noticeable if one's used to menthol on a regular basis.

I love Red myself, but my girlfriend really loathe it. I don't detect much sandalwood from it, but more chocolate? Nevertheless, I like it. A shame she doesn't.

I think my all time favorite shaving soap scent may well be Proraso White .

I found the red to be a bit irritating to me. I traded it.

It is ok to replace consumables.

Used the Red this morning for my shave. I always get a good shave from Proraso. A very consistent easy to lather cream for me.

I've only ever used C.O. Bigelow SC. I'm not as big a fan of SCs as I am soaps but I do like C.O. Bigelow. Could be menthy-er though, IMO.

The White has a very nice scent IMO

I agree and purchased mine at a retail store after smelling all of them. I prefer subtle scents.

I would say yes... If you run out, it must be replaced, or you won't have any... Makes sense in my mind...

I like the scent of the Red soap, but the performance of the green cream is just as good IMO.

I've tried the green tub and liked it. Never had menthol before so I can't compare it with anything. I like the performance though. I'm currently using the red tube and I really like the scent.

I've only tried the red and the green and can't really tell a difference between them. Maybe if I used them back to back.