I am looking for recommendations for a AS, or more importantly, a cologne, that pairs with citrus spice scent. I have a great shave soap that is very orange forward but a definite citrus spice. I love the soap. Any recommendations for a cologne or AS that would go well with it?

Chris - enjoying learning, whatever the subject

Check out Stirling's Aftershaves, the are VG / Excellent and they have several, that fall into the Citrus Spice category.

Perhaps Fine L'Orange Noir or Italian Citrus. Up the Ante and go for the Acqua di Parma Colonia.

I looked up the Acqua di Parma Colonia. Did I mention that I am cheap - grin. It does sound like a great scent though.

Chris - enjoying learning, whatever the subject

I’d say Woody’s for actual skin repair.
But for Orangey fragrances Tommy Bahama, aqua de goo, cool water. There are a bunch of sweet bergamot. Hearts and daggers is new to me, but it smells really nice and is inexpensive.



lol my iPhone changed gio to goo, I thought that to be hilarious.

I’ll second Joseph’s recommendation of Fine L’Orange Noir. It’s a near perfect dupe of Terre D’Hermes, great aroma, good longevity. I prefer it over the Fine Italian Citrus. It’s on the inexpensive side in comparison.

If you have a Marshall’s close by, I’ve seen tons of the Tommy Bahama that @david of central florida recommended. It’s discounted way off retail. I’ve gotten lucky and found Art of Shaving colognes at ~80% off.....

Pinaud Citrus Musk

Musgo real makes a spiced citrus scent.

https://clausporto.com/us/cologne-spiced-citrus

HBG offer two AS splashes that might fit the bill.

Key Lime
Florida

All natural ingredients. Soothing, not overpowring scent wise.

Both 4711 and Farina have mainly citrus notes. How can you go wrong with the original colognes ?

Any time I have a citrusy soap without a matching aftershave, I reach for M&L Florida Water.

Oz of the Outback.......has a tangerine note ,really nice.Aftershave and cologne set for less than 20 bucks including shipping, on the net at several sites.