What colognes/eau de toilette would you recommend that give a "clean" scent?

Something that gives that barbershop smell, or suggests you have just rolled out of the shower.

Something subtle, but with staying power - but not too floral?

My "old school" barbershop scent has always been Pinaud Clubman. To me, it's as authentic as they get and priced very well. Paid $7.50 at the local Walgreens.

Oh yeah, welcome to the den Cmdr Bond!

Welcome to TSD! I'd agree witth Bill that Clubman is what you've described. If you're looking for something higher end, Truefit & Hill 1805 is a more sophisticated scent in the same general family (though much more expensive).

T & H...my olfactory senses have gone into overdrive!! Someday I'll own a bottle.

Thanks for the response - and the welcome.

The T&H might be cheaper for me - dunno if the Pinaud Clubman is available in the UK.

I do note that the picture of the Clubman is aftershave lotion and not Cologne/EdT. I am specifically looking for C/EdT rather than just aftershave.

I will look into the 1805.

[edit] Looks like I can get the Clubman after all, for a 1/5 of the price of the 1805 cologne and 1/4 the price of the 1805 aftershave [/edit]

I think T&H still offers a sample pack with sample sizes of all the shave creams and aftershaves so you can try out a good variety without a big investment.

Spieck, St. Charles shaves Bay Rum with a lime twist. Both IMO are very clean scents.

While Clubman is labeled as an aftershave, it has staying power. I've been able to smell it on me 8 hours after I put it on (and not in an overpowering way).

I agree. Didn't really pay attention to the cologne/EDT part of the question. I just know that the clean manly scent kinda lingers all day.
But of course CB, you have to choose what is available to you also.

That is my absolute favorite!. I buy the Country Club size. My grandfather was a barber and nothing reminds me of the just left his shop smell than Clubman AS and I go the extra mile and use the talc as well.

Mugler Cologne is the freshest clean scent in a cologne/aftershave I've smelled.

I don't know if I would describe Clubman as a "clean" scent. At least to me it doesn't come across that way. I think the Pinaud Citrus Musk is more of a "clean" scent. I love it and when I wear it I definitely get whiffs of it throughout the day.

Yves Saint Laurent Rive Gauche Pour Homme!!!

Vetiver.

Speick Men AS. Doesn't smell 'typical Barbershop' but does smell clean, no doubt about it.

Lolita Lempicka au Masculin is noted as having a clean smell after the first 20 minutes or so. It is a non nondescript clean, like you took a shower. It is fairly cheap for a fine cologne, less than $3o bucks on Amazon.