I would like to get a rose scented soap/cream that isn't too much on the sweet smelling side and was hoping you guys could make some recommendations. The ones I know of are:

TOBS - Rose
George F. Trumper - Rose
WSP - SandalRose
Mystic Water - Sandalwood Rose
Mikes Natural - Rose Cedarwood
Catie's Bubbles - La Rose du Mechant
QCS - Rose Otto
TSD - Desert Rose
Le Pere Lucien - Rose de Pushkar
Soap Commander - Love

I'm leaning towards QCS, LPL, or the TSD soap but haven't been able to smell any of them. Obviously lather and post Shave are important as well. Thanks for any recommendations you can give.

Soap Commander Love is awesome smells just like well... roses

Oh yeah, I meant to put that one on the list but it slipped my mind. Thanks, now added to my list!

No problem man Soap Commander rocks!!!

JoAnna sells samples at the TSD Shop.

Pyrate's cove has a nice rose also.
soap commander love is very nice, the after shave balm rocks also.

I have tried Trumpers and ToB creams. Both have great performance but the Rose smell does not seem organic, more chemical. Still very nice creams.

Geo f Trumper rose cream is a great rose scent. Not sweet at all. Highly recommend

Mikes natural rose cedar is also very nice. Plus its a top performing soap.

My favorite rose is Rose of Bulgaria

I am a big fan of Rose and Lavender even Gardenia. Caties bubbles Rose Du Mechant is awesome. So is DR Harris Rose Crème. The best ever Rose crème is T & H ( Trueffit & Hill) Just absolutely fantastic.

Klar Kabinett if you can find it. Or Dusy Kabinett would be a great rose scented soap. I'm really interested in the WSP SandlaRose, the only problem is sandalwood causes me to break out

I loved my TOBS Rose. I only had a little sample of it from Maggard but it's going to be my next big tub after my sandalwood is gone.

I really like the TSD Rose and Lavender scent. I have wheat cream in this scent think it is a great performer.

Mystic Water Sandalwood Rose is not a typical rose scent, so if you are looking for that, then this soap isn't it. This scent is a sweeter one, but incredibly subtle and unique. The Sandalwood really blends very well with the Rose. I love it! However, YMMV!

I wanna try JoAnnas Rose and desert rose

I also want to try JoAnna's Desert Rose among several other floral offerings.

I recently tried and fell in love with a sample of Mama Bear's Sandalwood Rose. YMMV, but that Sandalwood Rose is a robust and beautiful scent. I'd go so far as to call it a perfect blend. I also got a sample of the plain Rose scent, and it smells like...a rose plain and simple but delightful. I prefer the Sandalwood Rose over the plain Rose scent but am in no way disappointed with the plain Rose scent.

I don't even find it rosy-scented! (But it's a good cream!)

This is also one I want! It's difficult with all these good products around

Wow! I'm not sure what to say to that. Maybe you should have your nose checked. Then again, maybe I should have my nose checked.