Use any aftershave you want and spike it with 3 or 4 drops of TSD M Bomb. Want it stronger? Add more drops. This guarantees you're using an aftershave you like the scent of, not one that is super cold but smells like the Veg.
Yeah, after a few years of tinkering with menthol I agree with Steve. M-Bomb will work and is a lot more forgiving than one crystal too many in a bottle of AS. And too much menthol is just that. Easy to add more, very difficult to remove it.
I agree that m-bomb or menthol crystals added to any aftershave you want is a good idea. some others include: Krampert's Frostbite TSD Iced Sub Zero a/s Osage Rub
Acolado Glacial. Nice and cold, minty scent, which isn't long lasting, so it won't clash with your edc. I love the penguin in the summer
