I'm not that picky hahah I've got the TOB St. James, and I just love the scent! Quite manly, but not in an Old Spice kind of way. More a fresh manly kind of way.
St. James is my favourite of the two, they both shave the same I just don't like rose scents. I prefer to look at them Regards, Paul
I got a tube of St. James and a tub Almond off of SMF, mainly because I wanted to try the Almond. I now want to get some St. James aftershave. The scent is like Misha says, fresh and manly. I too love the aroma. It has been well received at work also.