Still a tough one but here goes
5. Proraso Red Sweet sandalwood with that classic Italian soap smell
4. Stirling SDC A solid classic masculine cologne scent
3. Razorock XXX Fresh clean citrusy cologne smell
2. Blades Grim Smolder Sweet burnt vanilla masculine scent
1. Caties Bubbles Irish Coffee
Coffee cream and whiskey

Honorable mention
Cella Cherry almond
PdP 63 warm spicy french EDT scent

Sent from my XT1609 using Tapatalk

I like how you put some descriptions next to each one.

Stirling Black Cherry and Sharp Dressed Man. Arlington for my Sunday shave.

I'll go with C&S Oxford and Cambridge but find a couple of Mystic Water scents almost addicting (Green Fairy & Lemongrass and Blue Gum). I haven't tried the new formula of Lemongrass and Blue Gum menthol, however.

I honestly believe mystic waters has the best scents of any soap brand.

But they can be hard to lather.

Follow with Veg.

Carry on.

Perry, your two favorite Fines are my favorite Fines. Having said that, I haven't yet tried either, but just by description, those would be my two.

Wife loves Platinum on me.

Sent from my S8+ using Tapatalk

I like Wickham's Club Cola. That's the most "original " I have. By that I mean it is very different from anything else I have. A bit like ginger ale.
Tabacco Verde by Tcheon Fung Sing is very nice too. I have about twenty soaps/creams and those two are at the top of the list with respect to scent.

Lumby might be my next Rte 66 choice.

I love it. Don't tell @Salty Belle , but it's the best one....

well, that's good enough for me. Lumby is #2.

Update on the order of my soaps(with one added, one gone)

1.Stirling Barbershop
2. Rte 66 Cavendish.
3.Fields&Streams(Local Gent Shaving CO)*
3.WSP Sandalwood*

*these remain tied, as both are very good for their seasons.

Stirling Black Cherry my favorite. I also really like the smell of "Arlington". Although not as slick as I like I still use it for my Sunday shave.

Where abouts do you get the safari shave soap by ralph Lauren? It sounds really nice and would love to try it. Thanks!

My top 3 best smelling soaps would have to be

1 Stirling Electric Sheep
2 Caties Bubbles Quatra cent vingt
3 Uncle Jons Pipe Smoke

I do believe it has been discontinued for quite a while. Quite rare to find one for sale.

I absolutely love Stirling Electric Sheep, and Gin and tonic.

With so many new soaps in my den its tough to choose. My current favorites are the complex/difficult to categorize ones:
B&M - Diamond
B&M - Roam
CF - Civet
T&S - Shag


Others:
Tobacco - Henri et Victoria Cognac and Cuban Cigars
Earthy - Jabonman Tierra Humeda
Cologne - Nuavia Blu
Floral - MdC Rose
Citrusy - B&M Le Grand Chypre