-Colonial General SS
-Yaqi 3 Band Silvertip
-Stirling Island Man Soap and AS
@Linuxguile - Here is my take on this brush after it’s initial use. My feelings about it are positive enough that I am willing to make some general comments:
Let me rank this Yaqi, on backbone alone, with the other 3 Band Silvertips in my den, one being the best.
1.) Simpson
2.) Thater (1 and 2 are so close, it’s damn near a tie.)
3.) Envy Supreme
4.) Yaqi
5.) TGN Grade A (Yaqi and TGN almost too close to call.)
6.) Zenith
7.) Kent
8.) Edwin Jaeger (Vulfix??)
You could almost make 3-6 a tie, or call them indistinguishable from each other. Plus after one shave on the Yaqi, it’s hard to tell. I don’t think the Yaqui was a disappointment in any category. It isn’t snobby, its preference.
The way I see it......
Four or five years ago, when I became a shaving hobbyist, and there weren’t all of these choices, 2 Band was the new buzz word. Because Silvertip had been the pinnacle forever, it was king. But people (IMO) realized that maybe Finest, while it wasn’t something to brag about in terms of $$$, actually worked better, overall. And the 2 Band Renaissance was born.
That still doesn’t change the fact that traditional Silvertip is the softest thing out there. I will one hundred percent agree that the Yaqi Silvertips aren’t worth buying compared to their Finest. All the hair is chem treated now, all the tips gel up, why wouldn’t a guy want some backbone? But at the same time, these (3 Bands) have a face feel like no other. It’s the pillow of badger. I don’t haul sheetrock in my Towncar, and I don’t expect my F-250 to ride like a dream.
While I agree than any shave brush will work in any application, I have enough brushes now that I really pick them by condition of today’s shave. And there are times when man, I just love Silvertip.
TL/DR? I think the Yaqi 3 Band is a middle of the road silvertip, but a knot that performs above its price tag.
Click to expand...