January 12th
‘59 Flare Tip w Polsilver
Asylum (Saponificio Varesino) Colonia SS & AS
Omega Pro/Walnut
Thayers
View attachment 183608
A break from Jeeves January today. A few weeks ago, Joseph
@Primotenore and I came to an agreement on this SV Colonia combo. It was shipped to the border (AS has alcohol) and I didn’t have a chance to go get it until this morning.
It didn’t work well for Joseph, but I have enjoyed SV products and wanted to compare this soap base to the Felce Aromatica, which is also a ‘Beta 4.3’ base.
Full disclosure#1- I have never owned the original Colonia, any Aqua Di Parma products, or any of the other Colonia dupes that are out there. That being said, I loved the scent of this. Both on the puck and in lathering. What SV does with scents often really works for me. Again, I have no frame of reference for Colonia, though.
I heavily loaded with my big Omega and worked up a nice face lather. It did not, however, lather the exact same as Felce Aromatica. I got it to the slick appearance that I like, but by that time the knot was dripping quite a bit. I hadn’t had that before with SV. Took the razor to the face, and the soap was fantastic. Incredibly slick, and the razor just glided. Perhaps a little thinner, but great.
Afterwards, I used an SV splash for the first time. Full disclosure #2- I have the Felce Aromatica Splash which just arrived a few days ago as well, but have yet to use it. To be honest, my face is just a little dry. Joseph mentioned this as well. Not sure if this is related to the splash or the soap. I’ll use the Felce AS tomorrow (for science!) to compare.
I checked the labels as well and these are not the exact same ingredient lists. The first several ingredients are the same, but then there are subtle differences after that- either in ingredient, or in order (%) beyond fragrance.
First Impressions? I agree with Joseph that this base is not an exact match for other Beta 4.3 soap I have, and that either the soap or splash (or both I suppose) has a slightly drying effect. That being said, I love this scent. Just awesome. As well, the soap performed superbly during the shave- very slick. I might have an answer tomorrow on whether it is the splash that is drying after trying my other one.
Have a great day all!
Click to expand...