I have Ogallala Bay Rum Aftershave, Cologne and Special Reserve (double strength) cologne. The Special Reserve is the best for me because it's very strong! I also like Ogallala Bay Rum/Sandalwood. It has lasting power, which is mostly attributable to the sandalwood. Steve
I have Stephan's for now.....it's the only one I've used, so I can't compare it to others, but it's very good. Not for hot, humid days, though.
Meehan Bay Rhum Dominica Bay Rum Captain's Choice Cat 'O Nine Tails C.O. Bigelow No. 32 D.R. Harris Bay Rum All very nice choices.