Top Ten After Shaves Under $15

10. Thayer's Lemon Witch Hazel
9. Clubman Osage Rub
8. Brisk
7. Murray and Lanman Florida Water
6. Brut
5. Gillette Sport Cool Wave
4. Jovan Musk
3. Skin Bracer
2. Old Spice
1. Aqua Velva

Oh that Chaps was still in production. It would be #3.

 

I like your #'s 9,8,& 7.
In no particular order;

Several vintage Avon's; Wild country, Blue Blazer, Deep Woods
Vintage Shulton Old Spice, regular and Leather
Pinaud Clubman, Lime Sec, Citrus Musk, The Veg, Special Reserve.

 

Special Reserves
Pinaud Clubman
Avon Leather
Pinaud Citrus musk
Avon Spice
Nivea Deep ( the scent a little different, but it's very soothing)
Proraso (green)
Aqua Velva
Avon Clint (hard to find in wild)
Avon Oland

No particular order ..... It was hard for me to narrow them down ..... I could have easily went on to twenty.

I'm a scent guy, but I'm like a little bird ...... CHEAP, CHEAP, CHEAP!

 

10. Jovan Musk
9. Clubman Musk
8. Brut
7. Clubman Pinaud
6. Avon Spicy
5. Avon Leather
4. Clubman Special Reserve
3. Stetson Cooling Moisture
2. Pinaud Lime Sec
1. English Leather

 

1-9 Arko
10 Boots freshwood.

 

In no special order, these are hard to beat and all are less than $15 a piece. Actually, there are many more that I have at $15 or less that
are worthy and several more of them are AVON. Many of the AVON aftershaves (Sealed), that are 30/60 years old and still fantastic and
can be had a less than $15 for a 4oz up to 8oz container. I have about 20 AVON Aftershaves, that are still amazing. It does take patients to find
them, but they are well worth the search!

Stirling - Gentlemen
Stirling - Bay Rum
Stirling - Barbershop
Stirling - Sandalwood
Clubman - Special Reserve
Clubman - Citrus Musk
AVON - Brisk Spice
AVON - Wild Country Musk
AVON - Clint
AVON - Bay Rum

 

Clubman Original
AgadirMen(Oud Wood)
Russian Leather(from TSD store)
Mennen Skin-Bracer
Aqua Velva Classic Ice Blue
Aqua Velva Musk
Stoylin Sandpiper
Central Texas Soaps Weekend Rodeo(Leather)
Stoylin Gentleman
Old Spice(Shulton)


all in no particular order

 

If we're talking 15 USD I think almost all of my aftershaves came in below that price point - of course, for Chatillon Lux that's for half the volume so I think that precludes it from being competitive here. I won't list 10 but I would say Mickey Lee Reunion, Chiselled Face Summer Storm, and all the Maol Grooming scents.

If we're talking 15 CAD, AV original sport and Nivea sensitive I guess

 

Try thinking vintage.
Avon Spicy.

.

 

You got your Ma0l stuff for cheaper than I did then....

 

Concur fully with the aforementioned M&L Florida Water. I’d add Booster Polar Ice to the list as well.

 

I thought I remembered them being 19$ CAD but I just checked and obviously I'm thinking of something different

 

AV Ice Sport
Skin Bracer
Italian Barber Amici
Any RazoRock AS on sale

 

The legitimacy of any best of list that includes AV should be questioned. It may just be my humble opinion, but that stuff is utter crap.

I am simple regarding AS and have only used Superior 70 Bay rum for the last number of years.

 

I can only speak to the ones I've tried.

10. Gillette Cool Wave
9. Pinaud Clubman Classic Vanilla
8. Pinaud Clubman Virgin Island Bay Rum
7. Murray & Lanman Florida Water
6. Aqua Velva Musk
5. Aqua Velva Ice Blue
4. RazoRock Blue Barbershop
3. Pinaud Clubman Citrus Musk
2. Pinaud Clubman Lime Sec
1. Pinaud Clubman Original

 

I also like and use Superior 70 from time to time, but for me, it has no staying power, less than an hour.

 

That is exactly why I like it. Simple and light.

 

Nice list....My issue with Gillette Cool Wave is that it isn't that "Cool" to me. Smells pretty good, but they might do better by giving it a name that suggests it's a cologne dupe.

 

Thanks. Yeah. I only bought it because someone suggested it. I like the scent and I'm not a huge fan of menthol so the fact that it isn't exactly "cool" seems to work better for me. It made my list but it's at the bottom of that list.

 

Y'never know with a thread like this.....changes could be made left and right(if we begin to think about putting our favs in order).