I was very impressed today with Dr Jon's AS, which is very light, like a splash of water or witch hazel, with a good strong scent. I chose Runaway to match the soap, my first small artisan soap & AS set (I have Proraso Green & Red sets). If you're looking to experiment or expand the den, I highly recommend.
I really like their splashes as well. Some good face food ingredients, scent strength that is substantial but not overpowering, and I like that they’ve done scents that aren’t the “same” as a lot of the other artisans.