I've only smelled the bottle my dad has had sitting on the shelf for years, I've never actually owned it myself.
One Man Show, by Bogart is exceptional, as are all of the men's aftershaves and colognes, they have made over the years!!! Bogart Fragrances are Powerhouses and Very Inexpensive. Bogart Signature Bogart City Tower Bogart Witness Are among my favorites!
Lots of good suggestions here. I'd like to add Razorock Puros. Very tobacco (not the flower - think cured tobacco), pretty dang strong, and quite manly. Sent from my SM-N975U using Tapatalk
Since I haven't seen Norseman around, and same goes for the "big smile" avatar, I proudly present you the winner of the best goalie-mask avatar award.
Speick Splash. I am not sure how to describe the scent of Speick but it is very addictive. When I wear the Speick, I feel like I transform from a hairless chihuahua into a very hairy lumberjack. I get many complements on the scent. If you buy it and don't like it, I will buy it from you!
I am firmy in the camp of “Scents don’t have a sex.” If you like it and it works well with your skin, use it.
Is "cured" tobacco the kind that doesn't smell like that of cigarettes or cigars? (Notice I don't add pipes to that list-I manage well enough with pipe smoke).
Sorry, I don't want to smell Old Spice on my date. Come to think about it, I don't want to smell Old Spice at all. As for manly aftershaves in the fougere category, I think Whiskey Woods is very nice and more masculine than Clubman classic which I think a woman could probably pull off once it dries down to the powder/musk stage.
Lilac Vegetal With some of the awful things the uninitiated say about the scent, it has to be considered manly.
Paul, to me it smells nothing like cigarettes. Maybe slightly of a good cigar humidor. But if you have ever been in a tobacco barn where they dry fresh tobacco leaves, it leans more to something between that and pipe smoke. Sent from my SM-N975U using Tapatalk