Fair enough, Clint. I didn't remember you getting any Tabac.
I'm with you on Clubman. It doesn't bring anything to the table (performance or scent) for me, so I have no plans to use it again.
I can't say I love the smell of any shave soap. Arko was pushing my limits, but it performed well. I wouldn't go out of my way to buy more of it. I don't get a strong smell from Tabac (the smell I get is OK), but it performs as good, if not better, than any shave soap I've used. I'm over experimenting with all the new artisan soaps and being disappointed in the performance more times than not. (As for artisans, I will stick with Mike's and Stirling.) I do enjoy seeing everyone here try new stuff, and occasionally my curiosity will lead me to try something new. If I see anyone getting too serious about any of this, however, the voices in my head tell me that it is time for shenanigans.
Strangely enough, the only shave soap I would not use again is B&M Bay Rum. There was something about that one that I really disliked. In fact, I'm kinda over Bay Rum once I deep six my current bottle of CC Bay Rum AS.
The good thing about this place is that everyone can do their own thing and still be right.

Click to expand...