Here’s my favorites.
Unscented: MWF
Herbal: MDC Fougère
Woodsy: D.R. Harris Marlborough
Citrusy: Acqua Di Parma
Cologne: Razorock Santa Maria Del Fiores
Floral: PAA Mega Flora
Menthol: Myrsol Formula K
Barbershop: Antigua Barbearia De Bairro

added categories
Leathery: Abbate Y La Mantia Buttero
Musky: Chiseled Face/Zoologist Civet

I like Sir Hare "Classic Barber" also. Seems not many of us use this soap though.

This was an interesting thread bump for me…I looked back at what I said 5+ years ago, and would only keep a few on the list. The original First Canadian Maximo Gomez was such a great scent. The Reserve Cool (Floid Blue dupe) too. The rest wouldn’t make my list now.
I’d say my current ‘top of the shelf’soap scents that I own or have owned, in addition to the two listed, are:
SV Felce Aromatica
Fine L’Orange Noir
SV Desert Vetiver
Jeeves Tobacco Bay Leaf
Castle Forbes Lime
Stirling Autumn Glory

My tastes have morphed over the years, as well.

Here’s an update to my list.
Unscented: MWF
Herbal: Razorock Plague Doctor
Woodsy: PAA Black Shroud
Citrusy: TGS Royal Lime
Cologne: PAA Gondolier
Floral: Myrsol Plastic
Menthol: Stirling MITA
Barbershop: Wickham Classic 24
Leathery: Abbate Y La Mantia Buttero
Musky: Wickham Magnum

Someone here has caught covid and doesn't know it. With a sniffer like that you'll go far in the sewage treatment plant.

I really enjoy the scent of Institut Karite Paris Soap. It is a nice light powdery scent.

Unfortunately, it has been discontinued so when I am done with my current puck it will just be a memory.

Castle Forbes Lime

been a few years(2017) since i updated this reply..
current favorites;
b and m reserve waves
seaforth black watch
stirling sandpiper
a and e grecian horse.
and anything lime /citrus.

A lot of shavers love this lime, but personally, all I get is a blast of

Sabatoogee.

SW Pomona
B&M LGC
B&M Nordost
B&M Taiga
Stirling Haverford
Stirling Satsuma
Stirling Black Cherry
Mike's Naturals Barbershop
HetV Cognac and Cuban Cigars

Just checked my post from 2017 and found my favourites list is unchanged, partly due to not buying any new soaps the past couple years.

From 2017 post:

B&M - Diamond
B&M - Roam
CF - Civet
T&S - Shag

Others:
Tobacco - Henri et Victoria Cognac and Cuban Cigars
Earthy - Jabonman Tierra Humeda
Cologne - Nuavia Blu
Floral - MdC Rose
Citrusy - B&M Le Grand Chypre

Floral: I like Vida.

I like Vida.

The original formula Geo. Trumper Sandalwood and Geo. Trumper Rose are hard to beat. Also PAA Chocolate Bourbon

The minty blue Pears from Dollar Tree is seriously not bad.

Everything I post in this thread is from there. I'm a cheap b*std.

I might give Pears a try. They never did have a Rise Superfoam, and most of their products are advertised in the website for Rise(zero products from Rise in its own website).

havent used the "Classic Barber", but I'm close to finishing Hare's "Alpha". I'm enjoying that "rabbit" .

I haven’t felt the need to buy soaps in awhile, as I probably have more then I’ll ever use.

Chiseled Face: Ghost Town Barber
Chiseled Face: Orange Creamsicle
RazoRock: For Chicago
Stirling: Iced Pineapple
Stirling: Tea Tree
Taylor of Old Bond Street: Sandalwood