1. I always see threds about what are your top soaps performance wise?

    But what I’m curious about is. What are your top 5 soap/cream that you reach for and use the most frequently?

    For me in no particular order.

    Vito’s green from a kilo. As you will see,I like to use Italian soaps a lot.

    Proraso Green in the late spring through the summer and the red more for the rest of the year.

    Turkish shave sticks. Arko, Jikoryen get lot’s of use. Especially on work days.

    Razorock what the puck. The blue barbershop as it’s one of my favorite scents. Green is a nice one too.

    CBL seems to be the American artisan that I reach for the most. Usually on the weekends or days off.

    So that is my top 5 most used. Look forward to hearing, what your list will look like?
    brit, SDK, chazt and 2 others like this.
  2. These are most definitely my current top five. All are hard pucks except for the Mike’s (which is the hardest of all the artisan soaps I’ve tried). As you can see I have a strong preference for tallow based soaps :)

    MWF
    DRH Arlington
    DRH Marlborough
    Fine’s Snake Bite
    Mike’s Unscented

    A few honorable mentions that are super close in the six spot, but you asked for five :angelic007:
    brit and Ksblazer like this.
  3. I have been hunting for a stick of Jikoryen for a while now. Seems to be sold out everywhere…

    in no particular order

    Arko tub at home
    Arko stick for travel
    Stirling Bay Rum and Black Cherry
    TOBS in any citrus scent
    Cella
    brit, chazt and Ksblazer like this.
  4. in no particular order:

    vito's
    limoncello
    tobs shave shop
    seaforth
    zingari man..

    these 5 seem to be on the counter the most lately,with various others jumping the queue on a semi frequent basis.;):eatdrink047:
    blondblue, Ksblazer and chazt like this.
  5. Scents aren't terribly important to me, so I go by brands.

    For me in no particular order:

    Stirling
    Williams (Sadly RIP, but I bought a bunch at $0.99 as they were being discontinued)
    Dr. Jon's (Sadly RIP)
    Haslinger
    Did I mention Stirling?
    blondblue, Lockback, chazt and 2 others like this.
  6. My current favourites:
    Tabac (original/veggie) love ‘em both.
    MdC Rose
    Southern Witchcrafts Samhain
    SV Manna
    TOBS Peppermint

    Paul
    chazt, brit and Ksblazer like this.
  7. The soaps/creams I reach for most often are Tabac, Mike's, TOBS, Proraso, and Stirling. I've tried a bunch of different ones and keep coming back to these.
  8. Tabac
    Ethos
    Grooming Department
    Los Jabones de Josera
    Barrister and Mann 20230722_104345.jpg

    Sent from my SM-A536U using Tapatalk
    Ksblazer, awk-m4 and brit like this.
  9. Hoping @Ksblazer as OP doesn’t object. I’d like to modify my list just a wee bit… :scared003:
    Mitchell’s Wool Fat
    DRH Arlington/Marlborough
    Fine’s Snake Bite
    Mike’s Unscented
    Valobra/AoS Unscented
    Vintage Williams
    Ksblazer and awk-m4 like this.

  10. No objections



    While I have plenty of soaps and creams. I haven’t tried everything out there. So I’m enjoying everyone’s replies.
    chazt likes this.
    • Proraso Green
    • Proraso Red
    • Wars Classic
    • Wars Sensitive
    • Palmolive Rinfrescante
    Ksblazer, chazt, awk-m4 and 1 other person like this.
  11. All my soaps get equal use as I'm pretty consistent working the rotation. That said, I only use what I like and like what I use.

    Stirling
    TSD
    Tabac
    VDH
    Fine American Blend

    I have about 14-15 pucks I'm working through.
    brit, Ksblazer, chazt and 2 others like this.
    • Stirling Barbershop
    • Proraso Green
    • Cella Red
    • Stirling Bay Rum
    • Stirling Hot Apple Cider
  12. Limoncello shave soap? Link please.
    brit likes this.
  13. richgem likes this.
  14. 1) The stuff I make.
    2) The stuff I make.
    3) The stuff I make.
    4) The stuff I make.
    5) The stuff I make.
    brit, Herm2502, SDK and 1 other person like this.
  15. In no particular order:
    Grooming Dept.
    Shannons Soaps
    Ethos
    Noble Otter
    Saponificio Varesino
    Ksblazer, brit and SDK like this.
  16. Whatever's cheap...like me.

    Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
    Ksblazer, brit and Sara-s like this.
  17. Ya got any DIFFERENTIATION to your top 5???
    Sara-s likes this.