Art of Shaving balms are hands down the best one I have ever used. Very light but extremely protective. Trumpers Skin food is ok but the consistency is not as nice on your skin as AOS...in my experiences anyway.
The Art of Shaving balms are quite good, although a little pricey. For the scented varieties, I find the scents to be among the best for shaving products. Krampert's Finest bay rum is a also great suggestion. Although an alcohol based aftershave, it has something else in it that provides excellent skincare. Even after an irritating shave, the aftershave does not sting at all. The scent is the best I have ever found in an aftershave.
