In my inventory? The Gillette '58 TV Special is my current favorite. On my wish list? The Gillette Toggle, but I'd settle for a Fat Boy or a Slim as my first adjustable DE, which I think would take the number one spot in the hopefully near future.
My favorite would have to be my Exectuive, but I get a better shave from my short handle black beauty.
I've only tried two, my NEW LC and my Fatboy. So far, the NEW gets top vote, but I haven't had time to give the Fatboy a fair chance yet. My plan is to use it for most of November, and maybe December after OCtober is up.
I have not yet tried any vintage Gillette's. I have tried all the carts from TracII to fusion. Currently, my favourite is the Flexball. The reason is that it has never touched my face. Once I heard the rumors about the Flexball being released, I said "This is crazy. There has to be a better way". That lead me to discovering DE shaving. One day I hope to try one of the fine vintage Gillettes
1 iGillette (D1) toggle 1958 2 Gillette (f1) Fat Boy 1960 3 Gillette (k3) Slim 1965 4 Gillette (p2) Super Adjustable "Black Beauty" 1970 aka "The Black Pearl"
I bought a red tip on eBay last week and shaved with it twice so far. I used an Astra blade with Proraso white tub (my go-to soap). It was a mild shave but still very smooth after 3 passes.
Short handle Super Adjustable is the first vintage Gillette that has really stood out as a great shaver for me personally. I have and occasionally use a 40s Superspeed, Milady Decolletee (that I usually use with a standard handle), and a LC NEW. Previously had a SC NEW as well. I prefer my SEs and my Merkur Slant to all those, but the Black Beauty is now up in that top group, too.
After the '41 Ranger, that's probably favorite non-adjustable Super Speed. In fact, I was planning to shave with it tonight, thanks for the kick in the pants! *heads off for a shave*
Right now it's my New SC...even though I probably get a better shave from my fat handle Tech. Before long a SuperSpeed will enter the fold. My bets are still on the New SC. I love the way that thing looks!