I used some Clubman after my Saturday shave, and this is how my Bride described the barber shop scent:

"The whole second floor was fermented"
"Knocked me down"
"Finally went away"

So I'll be moving on to another aftershave. I guess I can use the remainder of my Clubman as windshield washer mix.

Anyone else have a similar experience?

I like Clubman SR but not Clubman but I did not need someone to tell me not to use Clubman.

Well, some folks are faster on the uptake than others.

My other rule of thumb for success in life is that if someone offers me a breath mint, I always accept it.

I sympathize with her.

I hope you are referring only to my use of the Clubman aftershave.

I have used it several times. First time it was way to strong. I have tried to tame it by mixing with witch hazel. Still to strong I think. About time for me to give up on it as well.

Hah! Yes, indeed, my friend. There's always been something in original Clubman that triggers a mild gag reflex in me. No idea what it is, nothing else does it, not even the Veg.

I like it. I am currently using Pinaud Clubman Classic Vanilla.

Dislike for the original Pinaud Clubman? I'm not sure if I like you all using the same internet as I do. I'm not sure at all.

I bought some to try one time and after one use my wife asked me what I used so I smilingly brought it to her, she poured it and out in the sink and said I would be better off letting the dog lick my face after shaving than wear that again. So no more clubman

I bet you never have any problems with clogged sink drains.

It was my wife's sink and come to think about it, it may have dissolved all her hair knots in the drain lol

The simpler solution is to PIF your wives and get new ones.

^^ This too^^

... but an extremely, extremely costly solution!

Both my wife and all my sons describe the Clubman scent as 'old' or 'cheap' or 'powdery.' None can abide it.
So I have nearly a full bottle after several years of ownership.

I really like Clubman. I got my dad hooked on it and he says "I can smell like I just got back from the barber without actually going to the barbershop everyday."

I for one prefer scents that aren't long lasting, but Clubman is a scent that I can have around all day. I need to buy myself another bottle.

Clubman was the first AS I bought as a teenager at the corner five & dime. Love the stuff. Course I love the smell of Arko too.

Lose the wife, keep the clubman.