There are some extremely good artisan soaps on the the market but for simplicity, TOBS and TOBS. Make one Sandalwood and the other Lavender, it wouldn't matter which one is cream just make the other scent soap.
Edit: I'll put in a plug for Salters SC too, hard to beat for the price, imo.

Proraso Blue
Anything from Mikes Natural

Soap - MDC Lavender
Cream - TOBS Rose

Noticing lots of mwf, mdc, and tobs so far.

so far
truefitt&hill ultimate comfort
and
Nana June's bay rum

Soap: Tabac
Cream: TOBS Sandalwood

Man these are always tough........



Soap: Anything Stirling
Crème: ..... uggghh!

Palmolive Classic!






But if you ask again tomorrow it will probably be Proraso in the Blue Tube!

Soap: Stirling or Mike's
Cream: TOBS Sandalwood

Looking like tobs creams are running away with it.

Soap - Stirling Barbershop
Cream - have not used one yet...

I could simplify it even more - just one soap.
Klar Kabinett.
Been using it for several shaves now and it's an amazing soap.

I need to get hold of some Dusy in the next few weeks so I can do a compare to the Klar and hopefully stop sweating about how little I have left.

Soap - Crabtree and Evelyn Sandalwood
Cream - Barbon

Soap: Tabac<-------I don't use it often just to savor it forever. lol ok i lied maybe i cant put it down for days once i start using it.
Cream: C.O. Bigalow<------- Its the first cream i ever owned and it will be my last. Its to trust worthy to not want it in an apocalypse.

Soap: Arko...I already have enough sticks to last two apocalypses.
Cream: Nivea Original.

Valobra stick, and Nivea Original.

Soap - Martin de Candre fougere

Cream - Cyril R Salter wild rose

Cella soap
Cade cream

There are so many great soaps and crèmes out there it is incredible! The last brand I tried is Caties and it takes a back seat to nothing