Not yet, but by coincidence I bought both tonight at the dollar store $1 each! I have later discovered that they don't smell all that great, but I'll find out about the performance sometime in the next week or so i suspect. Have you tried it yet?
It was sealed when I bought it- and upon sniff testing, it is doomed to go the way of the do do bird...
In Canada it cost me a buck and a quarter. I tried lathering it in a bowl, but it does not lather at all. I'll PIF it to someone that uses carts. It's designed in the USA, but made in China. I should have saved my money, added 50 cents and bought myself a Timmies.
It's not bad. I apply it with brush. It as citrusy scent and good lubrication. It's a great buy for a dollar. Don't let "made in China" put you off.
I've also seen it at the dollar store. I opened it up and the scent alone drove me to put it back on the shelf.