Good morning TSD
Day 1 of my comparison week - Merkur Futur vs. Progress
View attachment 90353
My setup today:
- Stirling Vanilla Sandalwood
- Mühle STF
- Merkur Progress on 2.5
- Gillette Silver Blue (#4)
- Tüff sensitiv
- Pinaud Special Reserve
After having used the Futur for more than 2 weeks I pulled the Progress out of the drawer for a comparison between the two Merkur Adjustables.
The two are very different in style and appearance, so it's a bit like comparing apples and oranges, even though they both come from the same manufacturer. The Futur looks modern and elegant (I'd go so far as to say it looks classy) with pretty clean lines, whereas the Progress has a certain "old school/retro charm". The Futur is 10 cm long and weighs approx. 125 grams, the Progress is about 1.5 cm shorter and weighs 95 grams. I think the Futur is a little more balanced, the Progress is a bit top heavy (though that can be a plus with shaving). Both are 2-piece designs - on the Progress you have to turn the bottom knob to unscrew the top plate, on the Futur you just pull of the head plate.
In terms of workmanship the Futur is pretty much flawless, whereas the Progress had some sharp edges around the bottom of the adjustment knob which I sanded a while ago because that really bothered me.
But now for today's shave. After a hot shower I loaded the Mühle Brush with Stirling's Vanilla Sandalwood soap. This Silvertip Fibre is growing on me. It actually feels pretty small for a 23 mm brush but it's a little lather monster. Very soft but at the same time enough backbone for a bit of massage. I produced tons of slick lather this morning ... though I think I have to get accustomed to the different water management with synthetics vs. badger
I took over the GSB blade from my Futur to the Progress for today's shave. With the first few strokes it was quite apparent that the Progress demands a different angle than the Futur. Not much, just a little. It shaves very gentle but at the same feels a little less efficient than the Futur (though that impression might change tomorrow when I use the Progress at a higher setting). And there's less audible feedback ... the Futur is a pretty loud razor. To my surprise I prefer the Futur's handle over the Progresses, although I usually like shorter handles.
The usual 2 passes WTG and A/XTG plus a bit of touchup at the jawline left me with a pretty much BBS face and a DFS+ neck - very nice. Absolutely no reaction to the Aftershave. Obviously GSB and Progress is a great combination. Now let's wait and see how long this shave lasts
It's too early for a final verdict but at the moment the Futur is at least one step ahead of the Progress. That doesn't mean that the Progress is not a good razor - it is a very good one and both are actually better (meaning more efficient) than the Gillette Adjustables I have used (Slim and Black Beauty).
Click to expand...